Home / Blog / How to choose a GEO agency
AI SEARCH
How to choose a GEO agency
GEO agencies are multiplying fast. Here is what they should do, what to ask and the red flags to avoid.
Written by Nikhil Narasipura Doddamane, Founder & Head of SEO/GEO · Published 25 Feb 2026 · Updated 9 Oct 2026 · 3 min read
QUICK ANSWER
How do you choose among GEO agencies?
Choose a GEO agency that tracks a defined prompt set across named AI engines, explains how it measures citations, can implement technical and content changes on your site, builds entity consistency and mentions, and reports monthly without promising guaranteed AI placements.
What do GEO agencies actually do?
A good generative engine optimization agency audits prompts, fixes AI crawler access and schema, rewrites key pages for answers, aligns company facts across the web, earns mentions on trusted sources and tracks citations by engine every month.
What does the research say about generative engine optimization?
Research presented at KDD 2024 (Aggarwal et al., Princeton University and IIT Delhi) found that adding citations, quotations and statistics can boost a source's visibility in generative engine responses by up to 40%, while classic keyword stuffing performed worse than doing nothing. The same study found lower-ranked pages gained the most: citing sources lifted visibility by 115.1% for pages ranked fifth in search results. Toffyjar GEO is included in SEO retainers from $499 a month (Starter) and $999 a month (Growth), with prompt tracking across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews. For buyers, the takeaway is that clear structure, cited statistics and consistent brand facts move AI visibility more than repeating keywords.
What questions should you ask a GEO agency?
Ask which engines they track, how many prompts, how a citation is defined, what they change on your site, who does the work and how results are reported. Vague answers usually mean a thin offer.
What are the red flags?
Guaranteed ChatGPT placements, secret methods, no prompt tracking, no technical changes, or reports that only show screenshots. AI outputs vary by user and time, so honest agencies report trends on a fixed prompt set.
How do types of GEO agencies compare?
The market splits into tools, consultants and full-service agencies.
| Type | Strength | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Tracking tool | Dashboards at scale | No fixes |
| Consultant | Strategy | You implement |
| SEO agency adding GEO | Existing SEO skill | Thin AI expertise |
| Full-service GEO agency | Strategy plus implementation | Higher cost |
How much do GEO agencies cost?
Prices vary widely. Toffyjar includes GEO in retainers from $499 a month (Starter) and $999 a month (Growth), with Enterprise custom. Compare scope, not only price: prompt count, engines, content volume and implementation.
Where should you start?
Run a free GEO audit to see your baseline, then compare agencies on how they would fix your specific gaps. See our GEO agency page.
What are the key takeaways on geo agencies?
In short: A good generative engine optimization agency audits prompts, fixes AI crawler access and schema, rewrites key pages for answers, aligns company facts across the web, earns mentions on trusted sources and tracks citations by engine every month. Ask which engines they track, how many prompts, how a citation is defined, what they change on your site, who does the work and how results are reported. Guaranteed ChatGPT placements, secret methods, no prompt tracking, no technical changes, or reports that only show screenshots. The market splits into tools, consultants and full-service agencies. Prices vary widely. Run a free GEO audit to see your baseline, then compare agencies on how they would fix your specific gaps.
WORK WITH TOFFYJAR
Want this done for you?
We build WordPress and modern websites and make them rank in Google and get cited in AI answers. Fixed quotes, senior review, you own everything. We measured these results on 16 October 2026 using OpenSEO, which draws on DataForSEO ranking and backlink data. For example, in one case study an enterprise digital engineering company whose site Toffyjar built has 65 non-brand page-one rankings, 37 at #1, with 2,717 referring domains. In another, an AI insurance process automation platform has 13 non-brand top-10 rankings including #1 for underwriting software, with 2,578 referring domains. These are current figures, not before-and-after claims, and client names stay private under NDA. Every site was planned from a requirement sheet, built on staging, reviewed by senior people and handed over with the client owning the code, content and logins. Projects are priced at about $199 per page, and SEO and GEO retainers start at $499 a month. Ask for a reference on a discovery call and we will connect you with a client where they agree.
CASE STUDY · ENTERPRISE DIGITAL ENGINEERING COMPANY65 non-brand page-one rankings, 37 at #1 →
Frequently asked questions
Are GEO agencies new?
Yes, most emerged with generative AI search.
Can a GEO agency guarantee results?
No, outputs vary; trends can be improved.
Do I still need SEO?
Yes, GEO builds on SEO.
How long before results?
Often 2 to 4 months for citation gains.
KEEP READING
Generative engine optimization → AI SEO services → AEO services → GEO agency → LLM SEO → What is generative engine optimization (GEO)? → Generative engine optimization strategies → What is AEO (answer engine optimization)? → AEO vs GEO: what is the difference? → AEO vs SEO → GEO vs SEO → Blog →NEXT STEP
Tell us what you need. Get a scoped quote in 48 hours.
*Save up to 70%: based on a $1,733/mo dedicated developer vs a $5,900/mo published US agency development plan (Oct 2026).